Journal of Social Aspects of HIV/AIDS/Journal des Aspects Sociaux du VIH/SIDA
←
→
Transcription du contenu de la page
Si votre navigateur ne rend pas la page correctement, lisez s'il vous plaît le contenu de la page ci-dessous
EDITORIAL INFORMATION/INFORMATION RÉDACTIONELLE Journal of Social Aspects of HIV/AIDS/Journal des Aspects Sociaux du VIH/SIDA ISSN 1729-0376 Editors/Les rédacteurs en chef: Dominique Meekers (USA), Elias Mpofu Prof Karl Peltzer, Social Aspects of HIV/AIDS and (USA/Zimbabwe), Kathleen Myambo (Egypt, Health, Human Sciences Research Council (HSRC), Zimbabwe), Charles Nzioka (Kenya),Walter Private Bag X9182, Cape Town 8000, South Africa. Odhiambo (Kenya), Kim Richards (USA, Zimbabwe), E-mail: KPeltzer@hsrc.ac.za Brooke G Schoepf (USA), Pieter Streefland (The Netherlands), Issiaka Sombie (Burkina Faso), Prof Cheikh Niang,West African SAHARA Office, Adegbenga M Sunmola (Nigeria), Jacques Philippe Institut des Sciences de l’Environnement, Faculté des Tsala-Tsala (Cameroon), Negussie Taffa (Kenya), Sciences, Université Cheikh Anta Diop, Dakar, Marleene Temmerman (Belgium), Leana Uys (South Senegal. Africa), Eliya Zulu (Kenya) E-mail: cniang1@yahoo.fr or ciniang@sentoo.sn Publisher/Éditeur: Managing Editor / Le responsable de la SAMA Health and Medical Publishing Group rédaction: (HMPG) Yoesrie Toefy, HSRC, e-mail: ytoefy@hsrc.ac.za Tel: +27(0)21-530-6520 Fax: +27(0)21-531-4126 Technical Editor/Rédacteur Technique E-mail: publishing@samedical.org Prof Anna Strebel Published quarterly (hard copy and online) Editorial Board/Le comité de rédaction: Publication trimestrielle (sur papier ou Internet) Collins O Airhihenbuwa (USA), Lewis Aptekar (USA), Peter Baguma (Uganda),Tony Barnett (UK), Funded by the Department For International Don H Balmer (Kenya),Yosiah DM Bwatwa Development (DFID) (UK) (Lesotho), Frikkie Booysen (South Africa), David Sponsorisé par le Department for International Celentano (USA), Maureen Chirwa (Malawi), Soura B Development (DFID) (UK) Diakaridja (Ivory Coast), Maria Eugenia G do Espirito Sato (France, Senegal), David Gisselquist (USA), Sanjay SAHARA J is listed on www.ajol.co.za and Garg (New Zealand), Seth Kalichman (USA), Ezekiel www.sabinet.co.za Kalipeni (USA, Malawi), Désiré Kamanzi (Rwanda), SAHARA J est listé sur www.ajol.co.za et Emmanuel Lagarde (France), Joe Lugalla (Tanzania), www.sabinet.co.za Winnie Mpanju-Shumbusho (Switzerland), SAHARA Journal Mission Statement The journal publishes contributions in English and French from all fields of social aspects of HIV/AIDS (care, support, behaviour change, behavioural surveillance, counselling, impact, mitigation, stigma, discrimination, prevention, treatment, adherence, culture, faith-based approaches, evidence-based intervention, health communication, structural and environmental intervention, financing, policy, media, etc). Déclaration de la mission du journal SAHARA Le journal publie des communications en Anglais et en Français de tous les domains des aspects sociaux du VIH/SIDA (le soin, le soutien, le changement du comportement, la surveillance comportementale, la consultation, l’impact, la réduction, le stigmate, la discrimination, la prévention, le traitement, l’adhésion, la culture, les approches basées sur la foi, l’intervention évidence-basée, la communication sur la santé, l’intervention structurale et de l’environnement, le financement, la politique, le média, etc). VOL. 1 NO. 3 NOVEMBRE 2004 Journal des Aspects Sociaux du VIH/SIDA 131
ORIGINAL ARTICLE Preventing mother-to-child transmission: factors affecting mothers’ choice of feeding — a case study from Cameroon K N Muko, G K Tchangwe,V C Ngwa, L Njoya ABSTRACT This paper reports on factors influencing the decision of mothers regarding the type of feeding method for their babies in a rural setting in Cameroon.The aim of the study was to ascertain the proportion of mothers choosing the different methods of feeding, to determine the various factors influencing their choices, and to ascertain the relationships of these factors to their respective choices. Questionnaires were used on 108 HIV-positive mothers who had delivered babies and who were administered nevirapine at least 3 months prior to the study. A focus group discussion with mothers also took place. Findings were that more mothers (84%) chose breastfeeding than artificial feeding (16%), while a minority (4%) selected mixed feeding. Factors found to militate against artificial feeding were cost (69%), stigma (64%), family pressure (44%), inconvenience in preparation/administration (38%), prior education from health workers (23%), and loss of special attention from family (8%). On the other hand, advice of health worker (44%), ill health (19.5%), free milk (12.5%), job pressure (12.5%) and loss of beauty (12.5%) were found to militate against breastfeeding. A direct relationship was also found between age, educational level, income size, marital status and choice of feeding. Policies targeting stigma reduction and socio- cultural factors affecting the choice of feeding are needed to optimise uptake of the less risky methods of feeding which could in turn contribute to a reduction in transmission. Keywords: HIV/AIDS, mother-to-child transmission prevention, feeding. RÉSUMÉ Cette communication présente des facteurs qui influencent la décision des mères concernant la méthode d’allaitement de leur nourrissons, en zone rurale au Cameroun. Le but de cette étude était de s’assurer de la proportion de mères qui choisissent de méthodes différentes d’allaitement, de déterminer les facteurs influençant leur choix et d’étudier la relation entre ces facteurs et les méthodes d’allaitement choisies. Pour recueillir des données, un questionnaire a été utilisé auprès de 108 mères séropositives qui ont des nourrissons. Ces mères étaient sur le traitement de la névirapine depuis au moins 3 mois avant le début de cette étude. Une discussion d’un groupe de foyer de mères a eu lieu. Les résultats ont montré que plus de 84% de mères ont choisi l’allaitement maternel contre 16% qui ont choisi l’allaitement artificiel alors qu’une minorité (4%) ont choisi l’allaitement mixte (maternel et artificiel). Les raisons contre l’allaitement artificiel sont les suivants: le coût (69%); la stigmatisation (64%); les pressions familiales (44%); les inconvénients liés à la préparation et l’administration du lait artificiel (38%); une éducation préliminaire de la part du personnel soignant (23%) et le manque de soins particuliers de la part de la famille (8%). D’autre part, les facteurs qui favorisent l’allaitement artificiel sont les suivants: les conseils du personnel de santé (44%); la mauvaise santé (19.5%); du lait artificiel gratuit (12.5%) et la perte de beauté (12.5%). Nous avons constaté une relation entre l’âge de la femme, le Kenneth Ngwambokong Muko (M Pharm, MPH) is a clinical pharmacist of the Catholic Health Service of the archdiocese of Bamenda,Cameroon. A former assistant lecturer of the faculty of pharmaceutical sciences University of Nigeria Nsukka, he is also the acting project administrator for Inter Care/Njinikom Project Hope, an HIV/AIDS prevention/care/treatment and impact mitigation programme in Cameroon. Koubitim Ginnette Tchangwe (MB BS, D Paed) is paediatrician at the St Martin de Porres Hospital, Njinikom. She also heads the mother-to-child HIV transmission prevention phase of Inter Care/Njinikom Project Hope. Valentine Che Ngwa (BSc, MB BS ) is undergoing postgraduate medical training in infectious diseases in St James University Hospital, Leeds, UK. He was the programme officer of the mother-to-child transmission phase of Project Hope and physician in charge of HIV treatment of the Catholic Mission General Hospital, Njinikom, Cameroon. Laah Njoya (MB BS) is the chief medical officer of the Fundong District Hospital, Cameroon. Correspondence to: KN Muko, Inter Care/Njinikom Project Hope, BP 16 Njinikom, Boyo Division, Cameroon. E-mail: ngwamuko_70@yahoo.fr Journal of Social Aspects of HIV/AIDS VOL. 1 NO. 3 NOVEMBER 2004 132
ARTICLE ORIGINAL Preventing mother-to-child transmission: factors affecting mothers’ choice of feeding — a case study from Cameroon niveau d’éducation, le niveau du revenu, le statut civil et le choix d’allaitement. Il est nécessaire de mettre en place des politiques visant la réduction de la stigmatisation et les facteurs socioculturels qui influencent le choix d’une méthode d’allaitement afin de maximiser une compréhension de méthodes d'allaitement à moindre risque qui par la suite pourrait contribuer à la réduction de transmission. Mots clés :VIH/SIDA, prévention de la transmission mère-enfant, allaitement. Introduction liquids or solids, there is continued concern that if no The majority of people living with HIV/AIDS are drugs are administered, the risk of infection is about women.Women aged 15 and older make up 58% of 30 - 35%.The risk is reduced to 20% if the child is the 42 million people who are living with HIV/AIDS not breastfed. Complete avoidance of breastfeeding (UNAIDS, 2002). Over 90% of these women live in (using artificial feeding) is considered the most reliable the developing world. Mother-to-child transmission way to avoid neonatal transmission.There is evidence (MTCT) of the virus — also known as vertical to suggest that exclusive breastfeeding for the first 3 transmission — is the main route of HIV infection in months may result in lower transmission rates than children under 10 years of age, with more than 600 000 mixed feeding (Coutsoudis, Pillay, Spooner, Kuhn & infants becoming infected with HIV yearly. Since the Coovadia, 1999). Improper use of breast-milk sub- beginning of the epidemic, an estimated 5.1 million stitutes (if mixed with tainted water or if over-diluted) children worldwide have been infected. Of those, the can cause severe malnutrition and fatal infectious overwhelming majority are in Africa.This is due to diseases.The risks associated with replacement feeding high fertility rates and high HIV prevalence in may outweigh the benefits. In sub-Saharan Africa, pregnant women, reaching levels of 40% in some cases diarrhoea is the leading cause of death in children (UNICEF/UNAIDS, 1999).The virus can be trans- under 5 years. A sound assessment of the safety of mitted during pregnancy, labour and delivery replacing breastfeeding depends on access to clean (perinatal transmission), or through breastfeeding. water, a reliable supply of formula, and availability of Among infected infants who are not breastfed, two- instruction. thirds are believed to have contracted HIV around the time of delivery. Some conditions that may increase The World Health Organisation (WHO) recommends risk of transmission during breastfeeding are the the following for mothers with HIV: advanced disease stage of the mother, maternal vitamin • avoid breastfeeding entirely when replacement A deficiency, breast abscesses or infections, certain feeding is acceptable, feasible, affordable, sustainable patterns of breastfeeding, and oral infection in the and safe infant. • breast-milk should be fed exclusively during the first months in cases where the mother chooses to Until recently, there was no means of preventing breastfeed MTCT for those HIV-positive women who wished to • if mothers choose not to breastfeed from birth or give birth.Two interventions using antiretrovirals stop breastfeeding later, they should be provided (nevirapine and azidothymidine) concurrently with with specific guidance and support for at least the feeding adjustments have proven to be very effective first 2 years of the child’s life to ensure adequate in reducing MTCT of HIV (Guay, Musoke, Fleming replacement feeding. et al., 1999; Shaffer, Chuachoowong, Mock et al., 1999; UNAIDS, 1999).The successful implementation of Other preventive measures jointly proposed by the these programmes is highly dependent on the choice WHO, UNICEF and UNAIDS include the and effective implementation of an appropriate expression of colostrum, artificial feeding with feeding regimen. For women who are HIV-negative, formula or animal milk, pasteurisation of maternal breastfeeding is the preferred child survival strategy for milk, reduction of breastfeeding duration or resorting providing nutrition and avoiding infectious diseases to a seronegative wet-nurse (WHO, 1998a;WHO, during the first 2 years of life.When a baby of an 1998b; UNAIDS, 2001). HIV-positive mother is breastfed and given other VOL. 1 NO. 3 NOVEMBRE 2004 Journal des Aspects Sociaux du VIH/SIDA 133
ORIGINAL ARTICLE Preventing mother-to-child transmission: factors affecting mothers’ choice of feeding — a case study from Cameroon As is the case with most countries south of the Sahara, and testing (VCT) surveys indicated 16.2% prevention of MTCT (PMTCT) is a target of seropositivity with 12.2% prevalence among pregnant Cameroon’s National Aids Control Committee.The women. Over the years (since November 2000) 2 864 country’s 11.8% HIV prevalence reflected a drastic rise mothers have been counselled and tested for HIV in among pregnant women between 1998 and 2000, and the health institution, and over 166 have been almost doubled from 6% to 11% among those aged administered nevirapine during labour.The 20 - 24 (UNAIDS, 2002).With pilot sites set up as programme currently has a nevirapine coverage rate of early as 2000, a gradual scaling up is taking place. One 63% (ascertained within the past year), as many province (North West) had 16 sites as at June 2002 mothers deliver elsewhere where their HIV status is (Kube, 2002).The policy with regard to choice of not known. feeding is artificial feeding as a first choice and exclusive breastfeeding if the first is not feasible. Even The study was carried out using questionnaires. though nevirapine is given free of charge, the mothers Trained health personnel administered tested have to pay for artificial food and other related costs, questionnaires to 104 mothers, and a randomly including treatment with antiretrovirals (ARV). selected focus group discussion with 18 mothers was held.The purpose of the study was explained to the Even though the WHO/UNAIDS guidelines on mothers and their consent sought prior to feeding in HIV/AIDS settings are quite clear, many administration of the questionnaire.The criteria factors affect mothers’ choice of feeding. Desclaux and excluded mothers who refused to participate and Taverne (2000) have argued that preventive measures those who were too sick to take part or had lost their applied successfully in developed countries cannot be babies.The inclusion criterion was all mothers who generalised. Some of these measures (like formula participated in the PMTCT programme, i.e. had been feeding) entail infectious and nutritional risks in counselled, tested positive, administered nevirapine and health contexts of low-income countries, where they delivered live babies at least 3 months prior to the are not economically or socially accessible for all study. women. Furthermore, HIV/AIDS-related stigma, and its associated discrimination, is known to negatively Results affect all aspects of HIV prevention, diagnosis, Of the 348 mothers who had tested positive for HIV treatment and care (Brown,Trujillo & Macintyre, prior to the study, 144 had been lost (had moved, 2001). Increased uptake of PMTCT services in delivered their babies elsewhere or died). A total of 38 general and improved adherence to optimum feeding had not yet been delivered of their babies and 62 were practices can be attained if factors affecting the choice either not eligible for the study or did not participate. of feeding of mothers are identified and appropriate Results indicated that the majority of mothers in the interventions put in place.This has not been done in study (84%) were breastfeeding their children, while Cameroon.Thus the current study seeks to identify the remaining 16% were using formula feed. However such factors and suggest plausible interventions for it emerged from the focus group discussion (FGD) improved uptake. that some mothers had initially used formula feeding before switching to breastfeeding. Methodology The St Martin De Porres Catholic Mission Hospital The age group 20 - 30 years had the highest number Njinikom is located in the North West part of of mothers (39%), followed by the age group of less Cameroon. More than 90% of the inhabitants of the than 18 years (30%), with fewest mothers in the age area are subsistence farmers with over 76% living on group above 40 years (7%).Table 1 shows the less than $1 per day.The institution provides health correlation of age of the mothers involved in the care services to over 170 000 people. In late 2001 an study and the choice of feeding. Exclusive breast- HIV/AIDS prevention, treatment and care programme feeding was found to decrease with increasing age and (Inter Care/Njinikom Project Hope) was put in place conversely an increase of artificial feeding was with the help of the British-based organisation Inter observed with increasing age. Care, Medical Aid for Africa. PMTCT has been a core component of the project. Free voluntary counselling Journal of Social Aspects of HIV/AIDS VOL. 1 NO. 3 NOVEMBER 2004 134
ARTICLE ORIGINAL Preventing mother-to-child transmission: factors affecting mothers’ choice of feeding — a case study from Cameroon of artificial milk. Conversely it was observed that the TABLE I. AGE OF MOTHERS AND CHOICE OF FEEDING more educated the mother, the greater the chances of Age Number Artificial milk Breastfeeding her choosing breastfeeding. < 18 29 (30%) 3 (11%) 26 (89%) Table 4 shows the marital status of the respondents 18 - 30 38 (39%) 4 (11%) 34 (89%) and their choice of feeding. A majority of respondents 31 - 40 24 ((24%) 7 (30%) 17 (70%) (55%) were married (71% of them from monogamous > 40 7 (7%) 2 (29%) 5 (71%) homes and 29% of them from polygamous homes). Widowed mothers constituted 19% of the group and it emerged from the FGD that some of them accepted The relationship between the income-earning that their husbands had died of HIV/AIDS. It was also capacities of the respondents and their choice of revealed from the FGD that some of the widows had feeding is shown in Table 2. Most of the mothers been inherited by their brothers-in-law, while some earned less than 1US$ per day. It was observed from had remarried. In half of the cases the present hus- the FGD that some of the mothers did not carry out bands did not know the HIV status of their wives any income-generating activity and were totally prior to marriage. It was observed that a greater dependent on their husbands or partners. Overall an proportion of single mothers involved in the study increase in income was observed to relate directly to chose to breastfeed their babies than the married an increase in the number of mothers opting for mothers.This was much higher among those who artificial milk.The relationship to income was not were widows. very strong for those who decided to breastfeed their babies. TABLE 4. MARITAL STATUS AND CHOICE OF FEEDING Marital status Number Artificial milk Breastfeeding TABLE 2. INCOME OF MOTHERS AND CHOICE OF FEEDING Single 17 (17%) 3 (18%) 14 (82%) Married 55 (55%) 10 (19%) 45 (81%) Income Number Artificial milk Breastfeeding (Monogamous = 39, polygamous = 15) < 1 US$/day 52 (53%) 6 (12%) 46 (88%) Divorced (separated) 8 (8%) 1 (13%) 7 (87%) Widowed 19 (19%) 2 (11%) 17 (89%) 1 - 2US$/day 23 (24%) 4 (18%) 19 (82%) 2 - 5US$/day 13 (11%) 4 (37%) 10 (70%) 5 - 10US$/day 7 (7%) 1 (15%) 6 (86%) > 10US$/day 3 (3%) 1 (33%) 2 (67%) Table 5 demonstrates the occupation of the mothers and feeding choice. A majority (40%) were farmers, followed by housewives (22%).The FGD revealed that Table 3 shows the educational levels of the respon- some housewives were also farmers and a clear-cut dents with their choice of feeding method. A large demarcation was not possible. Furthermore some proportion (41%) had less than 7 years of formal housewives also responded that they had no education.This was closely followed by those with occupation. No direct relationship was observed 8 - 12 years of formal education (29%).The smallest between mode of feeding and occupation. It was group (3%) was those with above 18 years’ formal however observed that among those who choose education, who held university degrees. Higher breastfeeding, the highest number were teachers education was found to relate directly to decreased use followed by farmers and housewives. TABLE 3. EDUCATIONAL LEVEL AND CHOICE OF FEEDING TABLE 5. OCCUPATION AND CHOICE OF FEEDING Formal education Number Artificial milk Breastfeeding Occupation Number Artificial milk Breastfeeding 1 - 7 years 41 (41%) 8 (20%) 33 (80%) Housewives 22 (22%) 4 (19%) 18 (81%) 8 - 12 years 29 (29%) 5 (18%) 24 (82%) Farmers 39 (40%) 7 (18%) 32 (82%) Teachers 11 (11%) 1 (9%) 10 (91%) 13 - 14 years 16 (16%) 2 (13%) 14 (87%) Students 14 (14%) 2 (15%) 12 (85%) 14 - 17 years 9 (9%) 1 (12%) 8 (88%) Other civil servants 6 (6%) 0 (0%) 6 (100%) > 18 years 3 (3%) – – No occupation 6 (6%) 2 (33%) 4 (67%) VOL. 1 NO. 3 NOVEMBRE 2004 Journal des Aspects Sociaux du VIH/SIDA 135
ORIGINAL ARTICLE Preventing mother-to-child transmission: factors affecting mothers’ choice of feeding — a case study from Cameroon Table 6. FACTORS MILITATING AGAINST ARTIFICIAL FEEDING Table 7. FACTORS MILITATING AGAINST BREASTFEEDING Cost 57 (69%) Advice of health worker 7 (44%) Stigma 53 (64%) Sickness 3 (19.5%) Family pressure 36 (44%) Free milk 2 (12.5%) Inconvenience in preparation/administration 31 (38%) Job 2 (12.5%) Prior education from health workers 19 (23%) Physical appearance 2 (12.5%) Loss of special attention from family 6 (8%) Discussion Table 6 reports some of the factors that militate Breastfeeding prior to the advent of HIV/AIDS was against artificial feeding.The most common factor was popular and this is reflected in the fact that the found to be cost (69%), closely followed by stigma majority of mothers were breastfeeding their babies. (64%). It emerged from the FGD that on average the Mothers who initiated formula feed and switched to cost of a tin of artificial feed on the local market was 4 breastfeeding reportedly did so because of cost and US$ and a baby needed approximately 36 tins within stigma.The fact that mothers took this decision in the first 3 months. Furthermore some mothers had spite of the awareness of the consequences of such a resorted to over-diluting the milk so that it would last decision shows the strong role these factors (cost and longer.The FGD also indicated that the perception of stigma) have to play in choice of feeding. stigma was greater than actual experience of stigma. Most mothers had not directly experienced stigma as A majority of the mothers were less than 30 years of such.Their fears were mostly based on experiences of age, which reflects the fact that in the area of study friends and colleagues.The FGD highlighted the women get married at an early age. Most of the connection between artificial feeding and stigma. teenage mothers were not yet married and the Historically, health workers have told mothers (and the majority preference here for breastfeeding could be community) that breastfeeding was the healthiest attributed to the fact that choosing artificial feeding choice for the baby. Many people are now aware that was synonymous to a declaration of their seropositive breastfeeding is not recommended for HIV-positive status and thus could decrease their chances of getting mothers.Therefore if a mother is using artificial feed, married. Furthermore strong family support has been relatives and neighbours suspect the reason is HIV- shown to increase adherence to feeding method and related. Furthermore it emerged from the FGD that the older mothers, most of whom were married, could breastfeeding mothers had a prominent status in the more comfortably adhere to artificial feeding as a society, so that they were given special food (sweet result of support from their immediate family, unlike palm wine which is erroneously thought to replace the spouses of single mothers who in some cases artificial milk) and a special diet that included eggs. refuse to accept their parental roles (Bassett, 2000). Mothers on artificial milk automatically lost this status. The programme in place encourages spouses to come for testing, and 36% of legally married husbands had Table 7 presents some of the factors that militate responded to this, while less than 5% of the unmarried against breastfeeding.The most prominent factor spouses of HIV-positive mothers had been tested.Thus (44%) was advice from health workers on the risk the legally married mothers had more family support involved in breastfeeding the baby. Some mothers and were more predisposed towards choosing artificial (19.5%) were too sick to breastfeed their babies, while feeding. others ascribed not breastfeeding their babies to their jobs and also the availability of free milk at the initial With 52% of mothers earning less than $1 per day it stage of the programme. Notable too were the was difficult for mothers to raise the $144 needed for mothers who would not breastfeed their babies a 3-month supply of exclusive formula feed. However (12.5%) because they were concerned that the the fact that some mothers resorted to diluting the appearance of their breasts would change and they milk rather than breastfeeding their babies showed a would look less attractive. strong commitment to adhering to artificial feeding in spite of the stigma. Increased level of education was Journal of Social Aspects of HIV/AIDS VOL. 1 NO. 3 NOVEMBER 2004 136
ARTICLE ORIGINAL Preventing mother-to-child transmission: factors affecting mothers’ choice of feeding — a case study from Cameroon expected to lead to an increased understanding of the mothers were more aware of the impact of their sero- greater risk of transmission in artificial feeding. How- status on their lives as a result of increased education. ever the study found that the higher the level of In the area of study, the higher the educational level, education, the less the chance of choosing breast- the greater the chances of getting a job, thus ‘working feeding. It is likely that the educated mothers inter- mothers’ are generally more educated.This is not the acted with peers of a similar education level who case with the farmers, most of whom had fewer years might have been more informed regarding the of formal education. rationale for artificial feeding and thus more prone to stigma.Thus reticence to use artificial milk may be a Apart from cost and stigma, which have been result of stigma and cost rather than the level of discussed as factors militating against breastfeeding, education. pressure from family relatives was observed to be a strong factor (44%).The FGD disclosed that relatives The fact that more single mothers than married who were aware of the importance of artificial feeding mothers chose to breastfeed their babies shows the in an area where breastfeeding was the norm were strong role that support from the family plays in worried that their families would be subjected to choice of feeding.The external family system provides stigma. Most members of the FGD felt that there was a strong financial resource, which is available when a no difference in perception between a mother who relative is sick. It would thus be expected that these gave the infant expressed milk and one who was married mothers would have greater access to artificial feeding the infant with artificial milk.This was milk than their unmarried colleagues. Unfortunately because the societal stigma would still be there and in in situations were stigma is high, it would be difficult some cases would be accentuated for a mother who for mothers to disclose their status, thus making it gave the infant expressed milk. Furthermore, the difficult for family or friends to help (Muko, Ngwa, inconvenience of preparing artificial milk (38%) was Chingang, Anke & Shu, 2003). In the area of study it mostly attributed to lack of time, rather than other is not uncommon for the disease to be referred to as drawbacks to artificial milk, such as the fear of ‘women’s disease’, an implication that women are diseases, e.g. diarrhoea and unavailability of clean solely responsible for the infection of their children, water, as reported in other studies (Desclaux & which contributes to misconceptions about the disease Taverne, 2000). Prior to the advent of HIV/AIDS, a and its effects, even though women often become great deal of emphasis was placed on the importance HIV-positive without ever having another relationship of breastfeeding; thus it will take many years for outside of their marriage. It has been suggested that people to accept artificial feeding as a valid alternative parent-to-child transmission (PTCT) would be a more free of stigma. realistic description that may lessen the stigma women experience (Brown et al., 2001). In the study, a mother who had recently delivered was given special status in the community.This was The preference for breast-milk in this study was accentuated for those who were breastfeeding, and associated more with stigma than cost. However more included a special diet with eggs, sweet palm wine, less widows chose to breastfeed their babies, probably work, etc. Mothers reportedly felt that giving the child because they did not have strong financial support artificial food would lead to loss of this special status. from their families, compared with their married colleagues. In the area where the study was Apart from the advice for mothers not to breastfeed conducted, the death of a husband entails huge given by the counsellors in the health institutions, the expenditure on funerals.Thus in most cases, the family clinical state of mothers was another factor. Less than finances would be spent on treatment for the deceased 2% of mothers were on ARV therapy, thus the chances husband. of infection from opportunistic diseases were great for a majority of mothers.The fact that some mothers Career mothers with stable jobs preferred to would give their children artificial milk if it was free breastfeed rather than to give their babies artificial further accentuates the issue of cost and availability as milk, in spite of the fact that they would be expected factors that could discourage breastfeeding. Few to do so less, due to the time spent at work.These mothers (12.5%) attributed their decision to give VOL. 1 NO. 3 NOVEMBRE 2004 Journal des Aspects Sociaux du VIH/SIDA 137
ORIGINAL ARTICLE Preventing mother-to-child transmission: factors affecting mothers’ choice of feeding — a case study from Cameroon artificial milk to their babies to pressure from their be naïve to assume that a pregnant mother could be jobs and some (12.5%) felt that breastfeeding would taking ARVs and replace breastfeeding with artificial cause them loose their beauty. Interestingly, these were milk without her relatives knowing her status.The the younger mothers who were not yet married. traditional values and their impact need to be recog- nised and impact-mitigation interventions put in Conclusion place. The study has shown that apart from cost and stigma, other sociocultural factors affect mothers’ choice of References feeding. For seropositive mothers, this decision is an Bassett, M.T. (2000). Psychosocial and community perspectives on alternatives to breastfeeding. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 918, 128-135. inherent determinant of the immediate risk of Brown, L.,Trujillo, L. & Macintyre, K. (2001). Interventions to reduce HIV/AIDS stigma: transmission of HIV from mother to child.The What have we learned? Horizons Program,Tulane University. pg 15 available at http://www.popcouncil.org/horizons/horizons.html (accessed 03/06/04). benefits of many PMTCT programmes may be Coutsoudis A, Pillay K, Spooner E, Kuhn L & Coovadia HM. (1999) Influence of insignificant if children who are protected during infant-feeding patterns on early mother-to-child transmission of HIV-1 in Durban, South Africa: a prospective cohort study. South African Vitamin A Study Group. Lancet pregnancy and delivery are contaminated during 354 (9177): 471-476. breastfeeding.The MTCT policies in place in Desclaux, A. & Taverne, B. (eds) (2000). Allaitement et VIH en Afrique de l’ouest. De l’anthropologie à la santé publique. Paris: Karthala. Cameroon and other sub-Saharan countries do not Guay, L., Musoke, P., Fleming,T. et al. (1999). Intrapartum and neonatal single-dose adequately address some of these issues, especially the nevirapine compared with zidovudine for prevention of mother-to-child transmission of HIV-1 in Kampala, Uganda: HIVNET 012 randomized trial. Lancet, 354, 795-802. strong influence of stigma. Utilising the terminology Kube, M. (2002). Preventing mother to child transmission. Biodiagnostics and ‘parent-to-child transmission’ may be helpful in this Therapeutics, 17, 3 -12. regard. However, the focus of interventions should not Muko, K.N, Ngwa,V.C, Chingang, L.C, Anke,M. & Shu, E.N. (2003).Treatment with highly active anti-retrovirals(HAART):Willingness to pay for HAART. Biodiagnostics only be on saving the child and providing for the and Therapeutics, 22(3), 3-37. long-term medical and psychological needs of the Shaffer, N., Chuachoowong, R., Mock, P.A. et al. (1999). Short-course zidovudine for perinatal HIV-1 transmission in Bangkok,Thailand: A randomized controlled trial. mother, but also on the father and if possible the Lancet, 353, 773-780. entire family. Furthermore, the provision of breast- UNAIDS (1999). Prevention of HIV Transmission from Mother-to-Child: Strategic Options. milk substitutes by the health care services and the Geneva: UNAIDS. UNAIDS (2001). New data on the prevention of mother-to-child transmission of HIV and issue of cost need to be addressed. Given the diverse their policy implications. Geneva: UNAIDS. socio-economic and cultural resources available to UNAIDS.AIDS (2002). Epidemic Update. Geneva: UNAIDS/WHO. women in Cameroon, it would be inappropriate to UNAIDS/UNICEF/WHO (1998). HIV and infant feeding. Guidelines for decision makers. Geneva:WHO. assume that blanket policies would be effectively UNICEF/UNAIDS. (1999). Children orphaned by AIDS: Front-line responses from implemented with expected impact in all areas. Health Eastern and Southern Africa. New York: UNICEF/UNAIDS. care workers should be given a central role in iden- WHO (1998a). Guidelines for health care managers and supervisors .WHO/FRH/NUT 98.1. Geneva:WHO. tifying what works in their specific regions. Evidence- WHO (1998b). A review of HIV transmission through breastfeeding .WHO/FRH/NUT based practices should be adopted in national policies. 98.3. Geneva:WHO. With increased availability of ARV treatment it would Journal of Social Aspects of HIV/AIDS VOL. 1 NO. 3 NOVEMBER 2004 138
ARTICLE ORIGINAL L’ascenseur et l’escalier — la lutte contre le SIDA au Cameroun Jacques-Philippe Tsala Tsala ABSTRACT HIV/AIDS infection has spread like wildfire in the countries of sub-saharan Africa. In order to fight that pandemic, Cameroon has organised itself by setting up, with the assistance of bilateral and multilateral partners, a national structure with the aim to reduce the spread of the disease.Two years after the launch of the National Plan for the Fight Against HIV/AIDS, an advocacy campaign targetting social leaders made it possible to assess the difficulties encountered by such an entity in a social and cultural environment as complex as that of Cameroon.The paper presents the initiatives taken by the government and analyses the major specific obstacles which are met on the ground.They include beliefs, social structures, gender issues, the status of women and the social representations of sexuality. If consensus and compromise are the usual ways of solving the problems raised at the national level, the analysis stresses the need for a more courageous political will adapted to the urgency of the prevailing situation. Keywords: HIV/AIDS, Cameroon, National AIDS Control Committee, National Plan for Fight against HIV/AIDS, resistance to change, public health policy. RÉSUMÉ L'infection au VIH/SIDA s'est répandue comme une traînée de poudre dans les pays d'Afrique subsaharienne. Pour lutter contre cette pandémie, le Cameroun s'est organisé en mettant en place, avec l'aide de ses partenaires bilatéraux et multilatéraux, une structure nationale ayant pour objectif de réduire la progression de la maladie. Deux ans après le lancement du Plan National de Lutte contre le VIH/SIDA, une campagne de plaidoyer visant les leaders sociaux a permis de mesurer les difficultés auxquelles une telle entreprise est confrontée dans un environnement socioculturel aussi complexe que celui du Cameroun. L'article présente les initiatives gouvernementales et analyse les principaux obstacles spécifiques qui surviennent sur le terrain. Ils vont des croyances aux structures sociales en passant par la problématique du genre, le statut de la femme, les représentations sociales de la sexualité. Si le consensus et le compromis sont les modes de résolution habituels des problèmes nationaux, l'analyse aboutit à la nécessité d'une volonté politique plus courageuse, adaptée à l'urgence de la situation. Mots clés:VIH/SIDA, Cameroun, Comité National de Lutte contre le SIDA, Plan National de Lutte contre le SIDA, résistance au changement, politique de santé publique. Jacques-Philippe Tsala Tsala is a professor of Psychology in the Department of Psychology, University of Yaoundé I and Catholic University of Central Africa (Cameroon). He has been Senior Consultant for the National AIDS Control Committee (NACC) since 2002. He has lead several researches and missions in the field in Cameroon. Correspondence to: Prof. Jacques-Philippe Tsala Tsala, Université de Yaoundé I, Université Catholique d’Afrique Centrale, BP 7011 Yaoundé, Cameroun. E-mail: jptsala@uycdc.uninet.cm/tsalatsala2003@yahoo.fr VOL. 1 NO. 3 NOVEMBRE 2004 Journal des Aspects Sociaux du VIH/SIDA 139
ORIGINAL ARTICLE L’ascenseur et l’escalier — la lutte contre le SIDA au Cameroun Introduction de l’Afrique à vouloir nier les spécificités de chaque Sur les quarante huit millions de personnes pays. Si la catégorisation sommaire a pour avantage de séropositives recensées dans le monde, les trois quarts rendre les actions plus rapides, elle est loin de parvenir vivent en Afrique, un continent qui ne représente que à l’efficacité qui suppose une observation patiente, 12% de la population mondiale (ONUSIDA - OMS, différentielle et contextuelle. 2003)! Face à une telle pandémie, de nombreux États africains se sont mobilisés, chacun à son rythme et à sa Qu’il s’agisse de la pauvreté, de la mauvaise manière, pour lutter contre ce qui apparaît de plus en gouvernance, de la gestion de la santé publique, des plus clairement comme une hypothèque sur l'avenir du problèmes de genre, de la démocratie ou des traditions, continent (Gruénais, 1999). Il est bien loin le temps de chaque pays se situe par rapport à son passé, à son la dérision qui faisait du SIDA ‘le syndrome inventé histoire politique, à ses susceptibilités historiques et à pour décourager les amoureux’. Les chiffres et ses cosmogonies spécifiques. l’ampleur de la maladie sont aussi venus à bout des stériles polémiques géopolitiques qui accusaient les Ces réalités n’ont pas les mêmes significations au regard Occidentaux d’avoir fabriqué le SIDA pour décimer de leur vécu et de leur gestion face à l’autorité l’Afrique ! La paranoïa de certains intellectuels et publique de l’État. Bien plus, certains pays doivent dirigeants africains proposant des théories les unes plus gérer des différences culturelles importantes au sein de étonnantes que les autres s’est réduite face à la cruauté leur population. Il s’agit donc de découvrir au des faits et à la réalité de la pandémie. L’Afrique bien préalable la finesse des situations derrière l’apparente pensante a courageusement cru qu'elle pouvait similitude des cas. rapidement donner une réponse médicale à la maladie. Malheureusement, l’utilisation du Virodène issu des L’objectif de cet article est de montrer comment un laboratoires de l’Université de Pretoria, le MMI d’un pays africain, le Cameroun en l’occurrence, réagit scientifique congolais (RDC) (1987), le Kemron du concrètement face à la complexité d’une population Kenya (1992), le Therastim de Côte d'Ivoire (2001) et spécifique et diverse. Entrepris dans l’urgence, les le Vanhivax du professeur camerounais Anomah Ngu différents programmes et actions de lutte contre le (2002) n’ont pas encore fait preuve d'efficacité. Ces VIH/SIDA ont révélé les insuffisances voire la faiblesse tentatives sont encouragées, soutenues et récupérées par et l’impuissance de l’État. L’incoordination des actions une idéologie africaniste qui caresse l’espoir de trouver — taxée par d’aucuns de ‘modèle dissonant de une solution africaine à un problème devenu politique publique’ — au niveau national et les ‘africain’ par la force des choses ! Face à l’ampleur et à injonctions contradictoires des partenaires la vitesse de propagation de la pandémie, la revendi- internationaux ont régulièrement été dénoncées avant cation politicienne doit momentanément céder la place la mise en route du plan national en cours (Eboko, à une action efficace et courageuse, à la mesure de 1999; 2000; 2002; 2003; Mbembe, 2000). Les enjeux l’enjeu. politiques de la lutte contre le SIDA au Cameroun sont réels. Mais ils ne sont pas suffisants pour que ce De nombreuses institutions nationales ont progressive- combat soit sommairement réduit à la seule ment vu le jour aux fins de barrer la voie à la instrumentalisation politique. Néanmoins, le progression de la maladie. L’ampleur du défi est telle gouvernement camerounais semble avoir pris que, vu la modicité générale des moyens financiers et conscience de ses lacunes en mettant en place — à la humains des états concernés, elles n’auraient pas pu demande injonctive de ses partenaires internationaux réagir sans le soutien de la communauté internationale. — un nouveau plan multisectoriel aux fins de limiter Ce soutien pose pourtant le problème de la marge de les contradictions et de reconstruire une cohérence manœuvre des États aux prises avec leurs populations indispensable au succès de son action. Notre intérêt et leurs difficultés spécifiques. De sorte que le SIDA portera sur les problèmes que rencontre l’application devient un enjeu de politique nationale et de ce nouveau plan sur le terrain. internationale (Gruénais, Delaunay, Eboko & Gauvrit, 1999). En effet, deux ans après avoir lancé son Plan National de Lutte contre le VIH/SIDA (PNLS), le Comité En effet, les divers programmes de lutte sont confrontés National de Lutte contre le SIDA (CNLS) a entrepris aux réalités d'un terrain dont la complexité ne cesse de d’organiser dans les dix provinces du Cameroun des dévoiler les contours. Elle reste pourtant vive, la ateliers de sensibilisation et de plaidoyer auprès des élus tendance des organismes internationaux et des ‘experts’ locaux, des parlementaires, des autorités administratives, Journal of Social Aspects of HIV/AIDS VOL. 1 NO. 3 NOVEMBER 2004 140
ARTICLE ORIGINAL L’ascenseur et l’escalier — la lutte contre le SIDA au Cameroun traditionnelles et religieuses. La participation à ces 253 ethnies pour près de 180 langues nationales, ateliers des représentants des associations des personnes dialectes et parlers à côté des deux langues officielles vivant avec le VIH/SIDA (PVVS) et des représentants que sont le français et l’anglais. des divers comités locaux de lutte contre le VIH/SIDA (CLLS) a transformé ces ateliers en lieux d’échanges Sur le plan de son organisation politique, le Cameroun fructueux, parfois ardus entre les participants, est une république démocratique et laïque. Les animateurs y compris. Les PVVS et les acteurs sur le religions dominantes sont le Christianisme et l’Islam. terrain ont fait des rapports détaillés des divers L’option républicaine de l’État laïc s’accommode tant problèmes administratifs et sociaux auxquels ils sont bien que mal des institutions traditionnelles que sont confrontés. De sorte que, à la fin des ateliers, les divers les sultanats, les cités — États musulmanes du Nord, les représentants et leaders communautaires ont fait des principautés territoriales de culture et de religiosité propositions concrètes aux fins de rendre plus efficace Bantou, les polyarchies fondées sur l’existence des la lutte contre le VIH/SIDA dans leur zone d’influence lignages dans le reste du Cameroun. Ces différents et de compétence. Les données à caractère autorités traditionnelles sont aujourd’hui intégrées à ethnographique que nous mentionnons viennent de des degrés divers dans le système de l’administration ces observations sur le terrain. Elles sont certes connues territoriale. On observe habituellement que des ethnologues et anthropologues et certaines se l’intégration dans la hiérarchie administrative a très peu retrouvent ailleurs en Afrique. entamé leur ascendante influence sur les populations et les sujets qui se réclament de leur autorité. En clair, Mais, au Cameroun, elles sont d’abord des éléments dans de nombreuses régions, aucune campagne de régionalisés et différentiés dont le PNLS devrait tenir sensibilisation ou d’information — fût-elle d’ordre compte. L’analyse que nous en faisons tient compte des sanitaire, éducatif ou politique, ne saurait se passer de divers contextes et de notre expérience de chercheur l’assentiment même tacite de ces personnalités relais et de clinicien en milieu camerounais diversifié. sans prendre le risque rater ses cibles et ses objectifs. D’où la délicatesse des campagnes de sensibilisation Après avoir décrit les mesures que le gouvernement contre la propagation du VIH/SIDA dans les provinces camerounais a mis en place pour lutter contre la et en zones rurales. pandémie, nous rendrons compte de la situation spécifique qui se dégage de ces nombreux et divers Une population jeune et irrégulièrement répartie échanges auxquels nous avons personnellement La population camerounaise se caractérise par sa très participé. Notre approche consistera essentiellement à grande diversité. On distingue: dans la partie exposer les principaux problèmes que doivent résoudre septentrionale majoritairement animiste et islamisée, les les différents acteurs de la lutte sur le terrain. Il s’agira Soudanais, les Hamites et les Sémites; dans le Sud non pas de mener une étude ethnologique ou majoritairement animiste et christianisé, les Bantous, les anthropologique des différents us et coutumes, mais semi Bantous et les Pygmées. plutôt de montrer la spécificité d’un terrain par rapport à un plan dit ‘national’. Nous reviendrons dans notre Le taux de croissance annuelle de la population du analyse sur les éléments qui nous semblent mériter plus Cameroun est passé de 3.0% en 1976 à 2.9% en 1987 d'attention pour rendre la lutte contre le VIH/SIDA et à 2.87% 2000 selon les projections (DSCN, 1987). plus efficace dans un pays africain, le Cameroun en Toujours à partir des mêmes sources et suivant les l’occurrence. calculs effectués par le FMI en octobre 2000 la population camerounaise est théoriquement passée à LA RÉPONSE CAMEROUNAISE À LA plus de 17 106 000 habitants. Les différentes PANDÉMIE projections donnent les chiffres de 18 000 000 pour SIDA et société camerounaise 2005, 23 000 000 pour 2014 et 25 000 000 pour 2020 Généralités sur le Cameroun dont 51% de femmes et 49% d’hommes. Rappelons à toutes fins utiles que le Cameroun est un pays d’Afrique Centrale d’une superficie d’environ 475 C’est une population essentiellement jeune dont les 650 km2. Il s’étire du Golfe de Guinée au Lac Tchad. moins de 14 ans représentent 43.7% de la population Ses principaux voisins sont le Nigeria, le Tchad, la totale. Ceux dont l’âge est compris entre 15 et 24 ans République Centrafricaine, le Congo, le Gabon et la représentent 20.5%. Soit un effectif cumulé de 64.2%! Guinée Equatoriale. Le Cameroun compte environ Le groupe des 25 à 64 ans représente 32.55%, tandis VOL. 1 NO. 3 NOVEMBRE 2004 Journal des Aspects Sociaux du VIH/SIDA 141
ORIGINAL ARTICLE L’ascenseur et l’escalier — la lutte contre le SIDA au Cameroun que les personnes âgées de 65 ans et plus représentent (café, cacao, coton), la dévaluation du franc CFA et une 3.26%. gestion peu rigoureuse des affaires publiques ont conduit le pays à un seuil de pauvreté jamais atteint On observe par ailleurs un mouvement d’urbanisation auparavant. Les années 90 ont été difficiles. Les important dans le pays. Ainsi, de 1976 à 1987, la différents programmes d’ajustement structurel (PAS) population urbaine a crû à un rythme annuel moyen imposés par les bailleurs de fonds et la communauté de 5.75%. Ce qui a entraîné le doublement de la internationale visaient à rétablir l'équilibre de la population urbaine en 12 ans. Celle-ci atteignait balance des paiements et les grands équilibres macro- 3 968 919 habitants en 1987, soit 38% de la population économiques. Il consistait en fait à réduire les dépenses totale. En 1995 la population urbaine était estimée à publiques et la demande intérieure. A ce jour, l’impact 45.3%. En 2000 taux est estimé à 50.4%. Les deux de ce plan sur le bien-être des populations commence grandes villes cosmopolites de Douala et Yaoundé à peine à être perceptible. Mais il apparaît clairement totalisent à elles seules 35.08% de la population urbaine que certaines mesures du PAS ont négativement affecté du Cameroun, soit respectivement 1 452 400 et 1 237 le bien-être des populations appartenant aux couches 500 habitants. L’enquête EDS (1998) donne les les plus vulnérables. Le secteur public a connu son lot indicateurs démographiques de base et les projections de difficultés. Des vagues de déflations du personnel et (cf.Tableau 1). une double baisse des salaires ont précipité les Mais une autre caractéristique de cette population est fonctionnaires et les employés des entreprises publiques la très grande diversité de sa densité en fonction des et parapubliques dans la précarité et la pauvreté. régions. En effet, selon les estimations de diverses sources Les données socioéconomiques (ECAM II, 1998; MINEFI, 2003), entre 1984 et 1991, Le Cameroun est un pays agricole qui connaît une le niveau de l'emploi a baissé de 10% et le chômage certaine autosuffisance alimentaire. Producteur de atteint le taux de 17% en 1995. Il frappe principale- pétrole, il exporte aussi le cacao, le café, la banane, le ment les jeunes et les femmes entraînant un fort coton. Mais la baisse des cours des matières premières développement du secteur informel. En 2001, par exemple, le chômage touche 8% de la TABLEAU I. DISTRIBUTION ET ÉVOLUTION DES INDICATEURS population active, dont 18.9% en milieu urbain et 2.3% DÉMOGRAPHIQUES DE BASE en zone rurale avec les pointes dans les villes de Indicateurs 1976 1987 2000 Douala et Yaoundé qui enregistrent des taux de chômage de 25.6% et 21.5% respectivement. Population Urbaine 2 184 242 3 968 919 7 668 000 La récession a gravement limité les moyens des familles Rurale 5 479 004 6 524 736 7 624 000 Ensemble 7 663 246 10 493 655 15 292 000 à prendre en charge l’éducation, la santé et la Taux d’urbanisation (%) 28.5 37.8 50.14 scolarisation de leurs enfants. La demande en éducation Densité de la population au km2 16.4 22.5 32.81 est limitée par le chômage endémique des aînés. En Taux de croissance annuelle (%) 3.0 2.9 2.87 effet, le taux de scolarisation qui était de 90% en 1990 Rapport de masculinité 95.9 97.0 97.3 Indice synthétique de fécondité est tombé à 76% en 1996. La déscolarisation et la non (1/1000) 6.0 5.6 5.14 scolarisation sont habituellement imputées à la Mortalité paupérisation des parents et à l’insuffisance de l’offre Taux brut de mortalité (1/1000) 20.4 13.7 10.1 d’éducation. Cette situation a aussi pour conséquence Taux de mortalité infantile (1/1000)156.5 82.9 77.0 Espérance de vie à la naissance de réduire l’autorité parentale et de pousser les jeunes à Hommes 43.2 52.4 56.7 abandonner l’école pour gagner plus rapidement de Femmes 45.6 56.2 61.3 l’argent dans le secteur informel et/ou dans la Ensemble 44.4 54.3 59.0 prostitution (chez les femmes et les jeunes filles). Structure de la population par groupe d’âge (%)* 0 à 14 ans 42.21 46.46 43.70 S’agissant de la prostitution comme effet de la 15 à 24 ans 18.94 17.77 20.49 pauvreté, elle concerne les femmes jeunes, mûres et 25 à 64 ans 35.65 32.49 32.55 parfois mariées (Garcia, 1992; Songue, 1993; Njikam, 65 ans et plus 3.20 3.32 3.26 1998; IRESCO, 1998). D’où le risque d’une plus *P = projections. Source: INS, RGPH (1976 et 1987) et EDS 98. grande exposition à l’infection au VIH/SIDA. Journal of Social Aspects of HIV/AIDS VOL. 1 NO. 3 NOVEMBER 2004 142
Vous pouvez aussi lire